Module 1.3 - Data Quality - Assessment

     This week's module focused on accuracy assessment. We were tasked to analyze the completeness of two Oregon road networks, one sourced from Jackson County GIS, and the other sourced from the U.S. Census Bureau's TIGER shapefile. This module defines completeness as the measure of the lack of data and the comprehensiveness of the dataset in representing real-world objects (Haklay, 2010). 

    In order to perform the completeness analysis, I first used the clip tool on the centerline shapefiles in order to remove any road segments outside of the county grid. Then I used the Summarize Within tool to calculate the centerline length totals by grid. This tool allowed for the total lengths to be calculated for road segments contained within their respective grid polygons.

    Positive % difference indicates that the Jackson County GIS dataset had a greater coverage, whereas a negative % difference indicates that the TIGER dataset had the greater road network coverage.

     Afterwards, I used the Table to Excel tool to export the summarized grid features in order to calculate a numerical summary of the results. I used the Calculate Geometry tool to obtain the area of a grid cell.

 

 

Module 1.2 - Data Quality - Standards

     This week's module involved determining the positional quality of two Albuquerque road networks against the city's aerial imagery. This module follows the procedures outlined by the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy (NSSDA). 

 

   The blue road network was sourced from the City of Albuquerque Planning Department, and the red road network was sourced from StreetMap USA. The red points are randomly chosen StreetMap USA intersections. Corresponding intersections in the city's planning dept. dataset and aerial imagery reference were mapped as well.

   In order to determine the horizontal accuracy, I first divided the study area into four quadrants using the Subdivide Polygon tool. This was necessary in order to obtain an ideal distribution of 20 test points as outlined in the 1999 Positional Accuracy Handbook by the Minnesota Planning, Land Management Information Center. After digitizing these points, I used the AddXY Tool to add the X and Y values to the three attribute tables. These tables were then exported using the Table to Excel conversion tool and entered into the Horizontal Positional Accuracy Statistic Worksheet.

     Using the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy, the City of Albuquerque Planning Dept. dataset tested 14.2 feet horizontal accuracy at 95% confidence level. Using the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy, the StreetMap USA dataset tested 163.8 feet horizontal accuracy at 95% confidence level.